Cosmo and all those girls that tell you that the main pre-requisite for dating a guy is personality are full of crap. Most psychological observations of adolescents and adults will tell you that being physically attractive is the first and most important factor in being well-liked and/or popular with your peers. And a night out in Hollywood will tell you the same.
I keep hearing, "man, those girls are gonna realize they're going out with fucking dicks soon enough." But dude, what's the point if they won't even give me that first chance? It never hurts to be a good guy, but don't buy into that bullshit from women about personality being #1.